My Photo
Name: Marsha Brofka-Berends
Location: US

Marsha knits . . . and reads and cooks and edits and gardens and hikes and thinks and eats and photographs and sings and writes and travels and plans and hopes and . . .

24 May 2007

"The Last Guy in the World to See Star Wars"

Here's a fun commentary piece just published on the Wired website: nearly thirty years to the day after Star Wars was first released, this guy finally saw it. He points out up front that he didn't go into the viewing totally clueless. It's impossible to have lived in our society for the past three decades without being exposed (heavily!) to what he calls "the fallout from this pop-culture phenomenon." In the end, he's unimpressed--and rightly so. This is an entertaining film but by no means great art. George Lucas's ability to write decent dialogue is nonexistent and, amazingly, somehow manages to get even worse over the course of the rest of the series, culminating in the gut-wrenching (for anyone who saw the film) palaver of the courtship scene in episode 2. His final verdict? "I should have waited for the 50th anniversary." Heh.

Labels: ,

6 Comments:

Imperatrix said...

I totally agree that the newer ones suck. And, the Ewoks were too fluffy. But the original! Oh, goodness. Han Solo. Adventure in the high vacuum. The Force.

It was the beginning of an era. Who cares about dialogue. It's show, don't tell, anyway, right?

Right?

(PS: Bloglines doesn't seem to be picking up your postings. They say it's something the blog owner needs to take up with the provider. FYI)

Thursday, May 24, 2007 9:20:00 PM  
Marsha Brofka-Berends said...

I hate the Ewoks almost as much as I hate Wesley Crusher. Almost.

Thanks for the heads-up on the feed. I've been having trouble with Blogger, including the fact that the feed gets published in the wrong place. I'll be switching to WordPress in the next week or so, complete with fanfare in the old location announcing the new url and feed information.

Friday, May 25, 2007 3:14:00 PM  
Slaax Gumbo said...

I'm a big Star Wars fan, but I agree that it was not the best crafted movie. George Lucas is great at coming up with stories, but not writing scripts. Also, the best George Lucas movies are those not directed by him either.

Sunday, May 27, 2007 10:38:00 PM  
arianna said...

Aw, I do hope it's not Wil Wheaton that you hate, it's just Wesley! :) Well, okay, I don't know him in anything beyond Stand By Me, but that is one of my all-time favorite movies. But, from what I hear about SW:TNG (I've never actually seen it), it is completely understandable that you are far from a fan of his character there. From what I've read, Wheaton wasn't a big fan of the character, himself. Isn't that right? :)

Monday, May 28, 2007 12:20:00 PM  
Marsha Brofka-Berends said...

Arianna, you are right: I loathe Wesley Crusher, not Wil Wheaton. Wheaton actually seems like a decent guy. He's got his own geek-heavy blog, so that's a good sign!

Monday, May 28, 2007 2:35:00 PM  
Gina said...

Well...I like the original Star Wars series. Yes, even Return of the Jedi, Ewoks and all. However, I think it should be noted that my favorite (and usually acclaimed "the BEST" of all the Star Wars films) is The Empire Strikes Back, WHICH was not directed by George Lucas (Irvin Kirshener did that job, THANK GOD). It shows. Lucas is a HORRIBLE director...and a pretty bad writer, as he didn't write the screenplay for Empire, either (again, THANK GOD). All adding up to why Empire is the best of all 6 Star Wars movies.

Tuesday, May 29, 2007 3:58:00 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home